Group health insurance for a small business
Fully insured, level-funded and self-insured plans, the small-group market and SHOP, and what Northwind's first plan costs it.
A group health plan is a promise the employer makes to its employees; an insurance policy is one way to pay for it. How it is paid for — its funding — decides who carries the claims risk and whose rules apply. There are three ways a startup meets.
Fully insured
- Good at
- The carrier bears the claims risk
- A fixed premium per enrollee
- State insurance law protects employees
- Watch for
- Premiums set by the carrier, renewed each year
- Carries the state's mandated benefits
- Best for
- Most small employers, and Northwind
Level-funded
- Good at
- A fixed monthly payment like a premium
- Generally outside state health insurance law
- Watch for
- Still a self-insured plan in law: the employer is on the hook past the stop-loss
- More moving parts — TPA, stop-loss carrier, claims fund
- Best for
- Small and mid-sized employers whose workforce is healthier than its rating pool
Self-insured
- Good at
- Generally not subject to state health insurance laws
- Plan design the employer controls
- Watch for
- The employer pays the claims
- Stop-loss is not health insurance under state law and does not cover everything
- Best for
- Larger employers with a predictable claims history
A fully insured plan buys a policy: the employer pays a premium and the carrier pays the claims. A self-insured plan pays claims from the employer's own money, usually through a third-party administrator, and buys stop-loss insurance against a bad year. A level-funded plan is self-insured in law but sold to look like a premium. Self-insured plans are generally outside state health insurance law — though the ACA's federal market reforms still apply to them.
The small-group market and SHOP
Most startups buy fully insured coverage in the small-group market, through a broker, a carrier directly, or the SHOP Marketplace. SHOP is for employers with 1 to 50 FTEs (up to 100 in some states), at least one employee who is not an owner, spouse or family member of an owner, and coverage offered to every full-time employee. SHOP requires that at least 70% of the employees offered coverage enroll (some states set a different rate) — a rule that does not apply to enrollments between November 15 and December 15 each year.
Step 1: Set the contribution
Decide what share of the premium the company pays, for employees and for dependents.
Step 2: Get quotes
Through a broker, a carrier or SHOP. Check the carrier's participation and contribution minimums.
Step 3: Run enrollment
Give employees the carrier's summary of benefits and coverage, and collect enrollments and waivers.
Step 4: Adopt a §125 premium plan
Adopt a written section 125 premium plan so the employees' share comes out pre-tax.
Step 5: Paper the ERISA plan
The plan is an ERISA plan: it needs a plan document and a summary plan description.
Step 6: Wire payroll and the books
Add the deduction, set up the carrier's monthly bill, and the accounts the plan needs.
Where this lesson's rules come from
The sources behind this lesson's requirements, by kind. Background reading explains; it is never the authority for a rule. Anything marked as a convention is ours, not the rule-maker's.
- Federal agency guidance
- DOL EBSA Technical Release No. 2014-01 (opens in a new tab)Self-insured plans, stop-loss insurance and state insurance lawFree to read
- HealthCare.gov — Find out if your small business qualifies for SHOP (opens in a new tab)SHOP: who qualifies, and the 70% participation ruleFree to read
- Background reading — not an authority
- Wikipedia, “Self-funded health care” (opens in a new tab)Self-funded health careFree to read
The words this lesson teaches
Each links to its glossary definition, which also names the authority behind it and the components that render it.
- Group health planA health plan an employer maintains for its employees — insured or self-insured. Subject to ERISA for a private employer, and to COBRA once the employer has 20 or more employees
- Fully insured planA group health plan funded by an insurance policy: the employer pays a fixed premium and the carrier bears the claims risk. Regulated by the state's insurance law through the carrier
- Self-insured planA group health plan that pays claims out of the employer's own funds, usually through a third-party administrator and with stop-loss insurance. Generally not subject to state health insurance laws, though the ACA's group market reforms still apply
- Level-funded planA self-funded plan sold to small employers as a fixed monthly payment covering expected claims, administration and stop-loss insurance with a low attachment point. Legally a self-insured plan, whatever the invoice looks like
- Stop-loss insuranceA policy that reimburses a self-insured employer when claims pass a threshold — per person (specific) or in total (aggregate). It insures the employer, not the employees, and is generally not health insurance under state law
- Small Business Health Options ProgramThe ACA marketplace for small-group coverage — generally employers with 1 to 50 full-time equivalents (up to 100 in some states), at least one employee who is not an owner or family member, and 70% of those offered enrolling. The only route to the small business health care tax credit